by Sarah Newton - New Thinking for a New Generation; Connect, Engage and Mobilize Today’s Youth
Spying on your teenagers online.
OK, I’ve been quiet about this too long and I can be silenced no more. I understand that parents are concerned and love their children but really, tracking all they are doing on the Internet? Is that really necessary?
As Norton launched it’s online family software that, “…tracks where you kids are going on the Internet. You can track what they are doing, what instant messages they are sending and what websites they hit…” I am getting more and more frustrated with this spy culture that we have online.
OK, let me explain it another way, imagine you are sitting down with a friend for coffee and they start to tell you that they follow their teenagers to school just to check they are safe, that they listen in their phone calls on the other line, that they have a hidden camera in the bedroom and turn it on when the boyfriend comes round or worse still, they nearly got caught peeking through the window of their friend’s house when they went to sleep over. Wouldn’t you sit there thinking, Gosh, this women is loopy? Worse still, imagine it was your husband doing this to you, would you call him obsessive? Wouldn’t this verge on controlling, abusive behavior? So what makes it OK for us to track every move our child makes on the computer?
I know I have probably upset some of you, but before you leave me a comment, heed this. After 7 years as a police officer in London, I can tell you that the surest way to ensure your child is safe is to communicate with them. And here is the clincher; if you spy on them and break down the trust you have with them, they are less likely to communicate with you, so your spying is counter productive.
Spying can never ever be a substitute for a trusting conversation that you can have with your child about concerns you have. Just think of how much respect and trust you show if you let them know that you will never put spyware on their computer, because you trust them to make the right decision and choices on-line, and then have a conversation with them about safety and what could go wrong, what they would do and how they would handle it.
And the real problem, in my mind, is what happens if you find something you don’t like. Recently, I had a parent on the phone explaining how she had been reading the chatlogs on her daughter’s computer and had found some reference to a sexual act. What should she do now? She was more worried now then she had been before. Firstly, she had read the message out of context so could never know the real meaning and secondly, she was too frightened to speak with her child about it because then her child would know she had been reading her stuff! So, one more worried parent who was in a Catch 22 situation. What a horrid position to be in!
Then there was another parent who confronted her child because she had read the messages on her daughter’s computer that said “dm me”, direct message me to the like of me and you. A big fight ensued and the daughter moved in with her Dad and will not speak with her mum about it.
How can breaking trust and respect in the relationship with your child ever be worth it? I have a saying that I live by and have my clients live by and that is, is what I am about to do going to move me closer to of further away from my child? If it is further away from, then don’t do it! How can spying ever move you closer to them?
Now I am not saying that there are not risks, but please get it into context, they are tiny. The risk of harming your relationship is far greater then the risk of something happening to your teenager on-line. Plus it gives a very clear message to your child that you don’t think they can handle problems well without adult supervision.
Saying this, Norton Family does have a great safe search feature and allows parents to block certain sites, which I think is a great idea. As a parent you have the responsibility to ensure your child is looking at age-appropriate material.
So, how do you balance trust and the need for supervision?
Firstly, I think you have to ask why you need to supervise. Is it because you feel that you should know their every movement? Do you worry about them unnecessarily? We must understand that teenagers will experiment, will make mistakes and will mess up; it is an important part of growing up and as parents we must learn to deal with our own feelings and emotions around that and not stop them doing things because we feel uncomfortable about it. Our dominant feelings may be stopping and inhibiting their normal development.
I think that first, when you approach your child, you must always come from a place of trust. Let them know that you just need to know they are safe, ask how this can be worked out. Not, “ I don’t trust you and I need to know what you are doing every minute!” Allow them the reins while also putting a container around their behavior.
So for example, give them free reign of the computer but let them know occasionally you will check their browser history (if they delete browser history, tell them they cannot use the computer for a week). This is far more trusting than installing spyware that your teenager will most likely be able to figure their way around anyway.
Encourage openness and honesty in the house and when your child does abuse your trust don’t punish them, just let them know that this is a trust issue and let them know that the consequences of breaking your trust is that next time the reins will not be as long; their job is to earn that trust back.
If you really are considering spying on your child, then first ask yourself how you would feel if it was done to you. Yes, you are a parent and yes, you have responsibility for them but not at the expense of their personal space and the respect we all deserve as humans.
Sarah Newton is an author, Gen Y expert, and contributing writer at Teen Checkup.
Get the latest teen tips at her blog.
Stalk Sarah on Twitter http://theteencoachblog.com/twitter
Fan Sarah on Facebook http://theteencoachblog.com/facebook
Don’t forget to listen in live to the Gen Y Guide radio show on Blog Talk Radio!
| From around the ’sphere:
EFFECTIVE: Talk with kids about online world
- To my surprise, they both agreed that it’s more effective for parents to talk to teenagers than to spy on them. “Talk with your kids about Internet use, just like you would talk to them about drinking, drugs, sex or anything else,” …
Skip spying, try talking - SantaFeNewMexican.com
- But is a talking-to from mom enough to protect teens online? I sought opinions from Dr. Herbert Mandell, a psychiatrist and medical director of KidsPeace, a 126-year-old national children’s crisis organization, and also from North …
Should parents spy on teens? - Living - The Olympian - Olympia …
- A report this month that MySpace removed 90000 sex offenders from its Web site had me wondering: Maybe all of those moms who spy on their kids online are doing the right thing. Advertisement. Yeah, that’s right. Moms are spying. … |
This post was written by: Erin
Tags:
norton family,
online spying,
spying on your teenagers,
teenagers trust,
tracking teens